Skip to content
Automobility Next: Skip what's noise. Know what's next.
Sun, 22 Nov 2026
Top Stories in 60 Seconds Powered by MarkNext
Automotive
Vinay Piparsania

Five Pillars for an Industry Under Siege: A View from Four Decades

Forty years after joining the auto industry, Vinay Piparsania argues that geopolitics, policy, product, energy and supply chains are now hitting automakers at once, and that adaptability, not prediction, will decide who endures.

vinay-piparsania

When I entered the auto industry in 1985 as an eager engineering graduate, a car’s most complex electronic component was possibly the integrated FM radio and cassette tape player.

Since then, I have seen oil shocks, the arrival of Japanese quality, emission norms that “would kill the industry”, the 2008 crash, and a pandemic. Each time we were told the industry would never be the same, and each time it adapted. This time, forty years later, it’s different.

The shocks are arriving together, instead of in sequence.

1. Geographical Turmoil: Resilience Over Efficiency

For thirty years we optimised for cost. Lean inventories and single-source suppliers made us profitable, and also fragile. A Red Sea diversion or a choked Strait of Hormuz can halt a production line thousands of kilometres away. When traffic through Hormuz fell roughly 70% after the strikes on Iran this February, Brent crossed $100, metal and freight costs spiked, and Indian suppliers warned that gas shortages would hit paint shops. The lesson is not to retreat from globalisation, but to stop worshipping efficiency as the only virtue.

Automobility Next: Skip what's noise. Know what's next.

Build “in the market, for the market” wherever volumes justify it. Hold strategic buffers on critical components, and map suppliers down to tier-3 and tier-4, because that is where the surprises hide.

India may read this as an opportunity, but opportunity is not entitlement. Becoming a credible “China-plus-one” destination requires reliable power, logistics and policy consistency, not just low labour costs.

2. Changing Political Systems: Policy Is Now a Product Variable

When I started, regulation was a compliance function. Today it shapes product strategy. Tariff walls, local-content rules, subsidy regimes, and emission mandates now shift with election cycles, and sometimes faster. In the US, the Supreme Court struck down the emergency tariffs in February, yet the Section 232 duties on vehicles and parts remain, costing automakers over $35 billion. An incentive that justified a billion-dollar plant can be rewritten before its first vehicle even rolls out.

Automakers must build political agility into their DNA: flexible platforms that serve multiple regulatory regimes, scenario planning that treats policy reversal as a base case, and honest engagement with governments rather than reactive lobbying.

For the Indian industry, the message is two-sided. Policymakers have been bold, from PLI schemes to the EV import framework to GST 2.0, which cut the rate on small cars from 28% to 18% and lifted the industry’s monthly run-rate by about 91,000 units within six months. The right policy moves markets, but predictability matters more than generosity: a stable ten-year roadmap beats an erratic subsidy every time. We should demand that clarity, and in return commit to localisation and investment with real conviction.

3. Changing Product Needs: The Customer Has Moved On

Let me be direct: legacy OEMs have updated their features, but not their development rhythm. Most still run hardware-first cycles of four to five years; newer competitors iterate in 18 to 24 months.

Today’s buyer, especially a young Indian buyer, evaluates a car like a smartphone, expecting connectivity, over-the-air updates, intuitive software and safety features once reserved for luxury cars. Yet software is too often bought in as a supplier bundle rather than built as a core capability, and the customer experience shows it.

India, meanwhile, reminds us that no single trend tells the whole story. The SUV boom, the growth of the used-car market, CNG holding above a fifth of retail sales, the rise of strong hybrids, and the return of the value-obsessed first-time buyer (54% of Maruti Suzuki’s sales in the first quarter of this fiscal) all coexist. Whoever delivers a genuinely good, safe, connected car at a mass-market price will own the next decade. Whoever mistakes premiumisation for the whole market will be exposed when the cycle turns.

4. The Energy Landscape: Move Beyond the Powertrain Debate

Few topics generate more heat than which powertrain will prevail. I have watched enough technology predictions succeed – and fail – to be sceptical of anyone who sounds too certain.

The transition will be uneven, regional and messy, and this year proves it. With no central purchase subsidy for private electric cars, India’s EV share rose from about 4.3% in FY26 to a record 8.3% in September, driven less by policy than by fuel-price anxiety as the Gulf burned. Battery-electric will lead in some segments; hybrids, ethanol blends, CNG, biogas and eventually hydrogen will each find their place. India, with its coal-heavy grid, its roughly 85% dependence on imported crude, and its extraordinary cost sensitivity, cannot copy anyone else’s playbook.

Two uncomfortable truths follow. An EV is only as clean as the grid that charges it, so vehicle and energy strategy cannot be separated. And charging, recycling and cell manufacturing are not side issues; they are the transition. Treat them as someone else’s problem, and you will run on someone else’s timeline.

My advice: a multi-energy strategy built on modular platforms that can carry several powertrains.

Bet on flexibility, not on ideology.

5. The New World Order: Supply Chains as Strategic Assets

We spent decades treating the supply chain as a purchasing function. The last eighteen months ended that illusion. China produces around 90% of the world’s rare-earth magnets, and its licensing regime now reaches even foreign-made goods with trace Chinese content.

In late 2025, a tug-of-war between the Dutch and Chinese governments over chipmaker Nexperia halted supplies of basic, low-cost chips used in everyday vehicle electronics, forcing Honda and Nissan to cut production, and Bosch to scale back plants. Semiconductors, cells, magnets, and critical minerals are now instruments of geopolitical leverage. Export controls can do what blockades once did, and the cheapest part can stop the most expensive line.

Every automaker should ask: which five inputs, if cut tomorrow, would stop us? Then act through dual sourcing, long-term partnerships, in-house capability where it defines the product, and urban mining – recovering lithium, nickel, cobalt and rare earths from used batteries, scrapped vehicles and e-waste. Vertical integration was once unfashionable. Selectively, it is returning.

India’s ambition for a domestic ecosystem in cells, electronics and rare-earth alternatives is the right one, and urban mining belongs in it. End-of-life battery volumes are still small, so this is a build-ahead bet, but those who build recycling capability now, backed by the Battery Waste Management Rules and the scrappage policy, will have secure supply when volumes arrive. Ambition without execution is just a slogan. Industry must invest alongside government, not wait for it.

The Connecting Thread

These are not five separate challenges. Geography drives politics. Politics shapes energy and trade. Energy and trade determine supply chains. And supply chains decide what an automaker can build, where, and at what cost. The Gulf conflict alone has touched all five pillars this year.

The real challenge is not predicting the next disruption. It is building organisations that can absorb several at once.

After four decades in the industry, one lesson stands out: the companies that endure are rarely those that predicted the future most accurately. They are the ones that remained adaptable when their assumptions proved wrong.

The next decade may belong less to the automaker with the boldest roadmap or the lowest cost base – and more to the one that can adapt without losing its direction.

The time for waiting for certainty is over. The leaders who make the hard choices and act decisively will shape the future of our industry.


Vinay Piparsania is an automotive and mobility strategist with four decades of hands-on leadership experience across global OEMs, markets and industry transformations.

Related Stories

View all →

More stories for you

Newsletter

Curated & Filtered for Leaders

The one credible, curated source industry leaders need to cut through the clutter.